Hello all
I am currently reading " The Great War at sea 1914-1918 by Richard Hough"
it is a very good book and thouhgt would the sea battle be any different if we had our battleships and desstroyers and other ship in like battle of Cornel and falklands and Juntland, I wondre if the battles would have turnes out any differnt? Would our Battleships have been any more effective aginst Germans Drednaights battle crusiers and others? I belevue out gunned the gremans? I would like to hear peoples thought.
Thanks
Aklua
General Topics
Post a replyWhat If Usa Did Join In Ww1 At The Begining?
4 posts
Interesting thought but the answer is no there would have been no changes for the simple fact that when the US joined the War the only ships to see any action were the USN destroyers in the convoys. The reason for this is that the powers that be in the US decided that the US Navy would be used as a defensive force and only used against a direct threat to the shores of The US.
Given that of all most of the Major Navies of the world at the start of WW1 ,which were British, Gereman, Japanese and US ( I dont count Turkey and Russian as they spent the war trying to get at each other), were on the same side, and the Germans were bottled up by the British Blockade. there was little chance of the USN sending out many ships. Besides Coronel and the Falklands were essentially the same campaign against two Ships the Scharnhorst and her sister ship which I can never spell so i wont try, and they were making a dash for Germany. but were brought down by the RN. I dont think that there would have been any US intervention. As to jutland there would have possibly been a few US Destroyers but thats about it so they would not have been a decisive force. Oh amd I doubt that the US would have been dumb enough to commit ships or men to the Dardinelles disaster.
Given that of all most of the Major Navies of the world at the start of WW1 ,which were British, Gereman, Japanese and US ( I dont count Turkey and Russian as they spent the war trying to get at each other), were on the same side, and the Germans were bottled up by the British Blockade. there was little chance of the USN sending out many ships. Besides Coronel and the Falklands were essentially the same campaign against two Ships the Scharnhorst and her sister ship which I can never spell so i wont try, and they were making a dash for Germany. but were brought down by the RN. I dont think that there would have been any US intervention. As to jutland there would have possibly been a few US Destroyers but thats about it so they would not have been a decisive force. Oh amd I doubt that the US would have been dumb enough to commit ships or men to the Dardinelles disaster.
Thats the one:)thanks East
Jump to
- Tides Community
- ↳ All About Tides
- ↳ Announcements
- ↳ ToW Web Site and Services
- ↳ Help, Feedback & Inquiry
- ↳ Soda & Coffee Shop
- ↳ ToW Entertainment
- ↳ TowNet Publications
- ↳ Media and Print
- ↳ Book Shelf
- ↳ Movies
- ↳ Short Stories by Tides Members
- ↳ Short War Stories by Vets.
- ↳ Music and Sound
- ↳ Soldier's Perls
- ↳ ToW Hobby Shop
- ↳ Internet / Multi-Media
- ↳ Youtube Gallery
- ↳ Game Modders Work Shop
- ↳ ToW Club
- ↳ ToW Club - About
- ↳ ToW Club Room
- ↳ FLH
- ↳ FLH Announcements
- ↳ GI JOE's Cantina
- by Land
- ↳ ToW:Army - Recruiting Station
- ↳ ToW Army Talk
- ↳ World of Tanks ( WoT )
- ↳ Lets talk World of Tanks (Public)
- ↳ ToW:WoT Battle Group Garage
- ↳ ToW:WoT HQ
- by Sea
- ↳ Admiral of Seas
- ↳ ToW Sea Talk
- ↳ Naval Action
- ↳ Naval Action - Lobby
- ↳ [Flot] Randolph's Raiders
- ↳ Randolph's Raiders - Quarter Deck
- ↳ The Central Isles Hotel
- ↳ Slippery Sam's Bar and Grill
- ↳ Front Desk and Lobby
- ↳ News Stand
- ↳ Red Tide/Wolfpack Information
- ↳ WolfPack Reunion
- by Air
- ↳ ToW Air-Talk
- ↳ DCS
- ↳ DCS - General Discussion
- ↳ [Sqn] 360th Fighter Squadron
- ↳ IL2:Battle of Stalingrad
- ↳ IL2:BoS - General Discussion
- ↳ IL2:BoS - Hangar
- ↳ [Sqn] 12.OIAE
- ↳ 12.OIAE Mess
- ↳ 12.OIAE Ops
- ↳ IL2:Cliffs of Dover
- ↳ IL2:CloD - General Discussions
- ↳ IL2:CloD - Hangar
- ↳ [Sqn] No. 616 Squadron
- ↳ 616 - Dispersal Hut
- ↳ War Thunder
- ↳ War Thunder Lobby
- ↳ [Sqn] ToW:Air Assassins Inc
- ↳ ToW:Air Assassins Inc Welcome Room - Public
- ↳ ToW:Air Assassins Inc Members Room
- ↳ ToW:Air Assassins Inc Officers Room
- ↳ [Sqn] ToW:Black Sheep Squadron
- ↳ ToW:Black Sheep Squadron - Welcome
- ↳ ToW:Black Sheep Squadron - Officers Mess
- ↳ [Sqn] =Brood=
- ↳ =Brood= Welcome Lobby
- ↳ IL2:1946
- ↳ IL2:1946 - General Discussions
- ↳ IL2:1946 - Hangar
- ↳ IL2:1946 - Flight Training
- ↳ IL2:1946 - Mission Workshop
- ↳ [Sqn] VF-10
- ↳ VF-10 Ready Room (Sala de Pilots)
- ↳ VF-10 Operations Room (Sala de Operaciones)
- ↳ VF-10 Hangar (Hangar)
- ↳ 01 SNATF - Announcements
- ↳ 02 SNATF - Gen Discussion Forum
- ↳ 03 SNATF - Event Results
- ↳ 04 SNATF Registration
- ↳ 05 SNATF OPS
- ↳ 06 SNATF WEB SITE
- ↳ The Tin Man
- ↳ MCVG-2 Command Room
- ↳ MCVG-2 Training Room
- ↳ MCVG-2 Air Ops
- ↳ MCVG-2 Web Site
- ↳ MCVG-2 Recruiting Office
- ↳ IL2 Hangar
- ↳ MCVG-2 CiC
- ↳ CVG-12 Manuals
- ↳ Ground Training
- ↳ Old Training Forum
- ↳ Recognition Training
- ↳ Pilots Notes
- ↳ Radio Telephony Manual
- ↳ Flying Training
- ↳ Combat Training
- ↳ 1stAVBG - California Club
- ↳ 1stAVBG - Recruiting Office
- ↳ 1stAVBG Website
- ↳ 1stAVBG HQ
- ↳ 1stAVBG - HQ
- ↳ 1stAVBG - Rank and Awards
- ↳ 1stAVBG - Training
- ↳ 1stAVBG - Missions Briefing
- ↳ 1stAVBG - Recon
- ↳ 1stAVBG - Mods
- ↳ 117th Open Topic
- ↳ 117th HQ
- ↳ 117th Sortie Schedule
- ↳ 117th After Action Reports
- ↳ [Sqn] No. 85 Squadron
- ↳ 85 - Mess
- ↳ 85 - Operations
- by Space
- ↳ -- SPACE TALK --
- ↳ Voice Commands
- ↳ Star Trek Online - STO
- ↳ Star Trek Online - General Discussion
- ↳ [Fleet] Tides of War
- ↳ STO - ToW Data Bank
- ↳ STO - ToW Federation Fleet HQ
- ↳ STO - ToW Klingon Fleet HQ
- ↳ STO - ToW Fleet Command Center
- ↳ STO - Klingon Operations Center
- ↳ STO - Federation Operation Center
- ↳ Star Citizen
- ↳ SC - General Information
- ↳ SC - Vids
- ↳ SC - Discussion Forum
- ↳ SC - Squadron 42
- ↳ SC - We Want You...
- ↳ Eve Online
- ↳ General
- ↳ [Corp] Metacrania Corp
- ↳ Lobby
- ↳ Metacrania Corp ViP's
- ↳ Elite: Dangerous
- by Fantasy
- ↳ World of Warcraft
- ↳ Feral Muffins
- ↳ Raiding
- ↳ Archive
- ↳ Dark Venom
- ↳ News
- ↳ The Broken Keel
- ↳ Silent Killers
- ↳ The Blood Blades
- ↳ The Ingos
- ↳ Horde on Tour
- ↳ Tribes of War Coalition
- ↳ Tribes Raiding
- ↳ Death Angels
- ↳ CoD5 WaW
- ↳ TEST by Tbar
- Tides of War Archive
- ↳ by Land
- ↳ Armored Warfare
- ↳ Call of Duty Series
- ↳ Call Of Duty games 1-6
- ↳ Call of Duty 7: Black Ops
- ↳ BattleField Series
- ↳ BattleField Chat
- ↳ by Sea
- ↳ Steel Waves
- ↳ Deepolis
- ↳ Deepolis Fan Site
- ↳ Deepolis Fan Site Forums
- ↳ by Air
- ↳ Air Marshal
- ↳ Rise of Flight
- ↳ RoF - General
- ↳ RoF - Hangar
- ↳ RoF ToW Fighter Wing
- ↳ [Sqn] = I R F C =
- ↳ Air Attack Game v1.0
- ↳ Air Attack Lobby
- ↳ ToW League Air Attack
- ↳ 1x1 League
- ↳ 2x2
- ↳ 4 Squad Sim
- ↳ AA - Flight School
- ↳ [Sqn] VMF-214 Black Sheep Squadron
- ↳ BSS Pilots Lounge
- ↳ BSS Sortie Schedule
- ↳ BSS: Off Duty
- ↳ BSS Archives
- ↳ BSS CO/XO Board
- ↳ SNL-KTF Tactical
- ↳ [Sqn] Air Assassins
- ↳ The Air Pirates Lounge
- ↳ Air Ops
- ↳ [Sqn] The Empire Aces
- ↳ TEA Public Lounge
- ↳ TEA Private
- ↳ [Sqn] USAAC - Air Attack - Archive
- ↳ USAAC - AA Pilot Lounge
- ↳ USAAC - AA Pilot Operations Forum
- ↳ USAAC Leagues & Events
- ↳ Leagues
- ↳ Fun Events
- ↳ USAAC - AA FAQ
- ↳ USAAC - Flight School
- ↳ USAAC - Squad Forums
- ↳ AA Squads/Teams/Links
- ↳ USAAC - CO/XO and STAFF Board
- ↳ USAAC League and Events Mgmt
- ↳ USAAC Fun Events Mgmt
- ↳ USAAC League Mgmt
- ↳ USAAC Refs Board
- ↳ USAAC Web Works Dept
- ↳ USAAC ** CITY HALL **
- ↳ Great Hall
- ↳ USAAC Archives
- ↳ by Space
- ↳ Mission Control
- ↳ Space Engineers
- ↳ by Fantasy
- ↳ -- FANTASY GAMES --
- ↳ Fire Fall
- ↳ ToW Army Group HQ
- ↳ Shroud of the Avatar
- ↳ Left 4 Dead
- ↳ Halo
- ↳ Halo 1
- ↳ Halo 2
- ↳ Federation - II
- ↳ Phantasy Star Universe
- ↳ Table Top
- ↳ Abbeywood Irregulars
- ↳ Brigade Office
- ↳ Operations
- ↳ Deployments
- ↳ Afterwind - Browser Turn Based
- ↳ Enigma - Rising Tide - Archive
- ↳ Fleet Headquarters
- ↳ Captains Quarters
- ↳ General Topics
- ↳ Roll Call
- ↳ Screenshots
- ↳ War Stories
- ↳ The Raid on Scapa Flow
- ↳ General Topics
- ↳ Briefing Room
- ↳ Briefing Room Imperial Germany
- ↳ Briefing Room Royal Navy in Exile
- ↳ Briefing Room United States of America
- ↳ Engineroom
- ↳ Sink The Hood
- ↳ Future Suggestions
- ↳ Community Modding
- ↳ Custom Missions
- ↳ Game Modding
- ↳ Voice Packs
- ↳ Massive Multiplayer